They all like me but I can only have 1?

It's a nightmare! They all like me! Ughh so the first ones I dated for like a week but then we took a break and started being just friends but he still really likes me. He's cute and sweet and he says he always thinks about me. I really like him 2 but he's wayy skinnier than me and I'm not even fat I'm pretty skinny myself. I still think he's cute though. Ok guy #2 is a longtime friend who has turned into a friend with benefits lol he kisses me and holds me but not in public. He's sweet and we r great friends but he's dated sooo many of my friends. Guy #3 is not extremely cute but he's alright. He's alil older than me but he plays guitar and he is amazing at flirting and just being himself. I heard he's a man whore cuzz he dated alot of girls and it feels like he would cheat but I'm still in shock that he likes me!! I like them all but idk who I like most! Wichita 2 should stay as friends and Wichita 1 should win my heart?? :/ thanks